Best Dumpster Size for Roof Tear-Off: 15 vs 20 Yard
Best Dumpster Size for Roof Tear-Off: 15 vs 20 Yard
When you're standing in the driveway looking up at a roof that needs to come off, the last thing you want is to guess on dumpster size. Order too small and you're stuck paying for a second haul. Order too big and you're wasting money on space you don't need.
Here's exactly how to choose between a 15-yard and 20-yard dumpster for your roofing project — based on real jobs we've handled across Cincinnati and Northern Kentucky.
---
How Much Does a Roof Tear-Off Actually Weigh?
Asphalt shingles are deceptively heavy. According to the National Roofing Contractors Association (NRCA), a single bundle of three-tab shingles weighs 60–80 lbs, and architectural shingles run 65–80 lbs per bundle.
Here's the math for a typical residential roof:
One "square" = 100 sq ft of roof area. Most Cincinnati-area homes have 20–30 square roofs.
---
When the 15-Yard Dumpster Works
Our 15-yard dumpster is the go-to for most single-layer residential roofing jobs:
- Roof size: Up to 25 squares (2,500 sq ft)
- Single layer of shingles
- No additional debris (gutters, fascia, decking)
- Weight range: Up to ~5,000 lbs comfortably
---
When You Need the 20-Yard
Step up to the 20-yard dumpster when:
- Roof size exceeds 25 squares (most two-story colonials)
- Multiple layers — ripping off 2 or 3 layers doubles/triples the weight
- You're also replacing gutters, fascia, or damaged decking
- Architectural shingles — heavier per bundle than three-tab
---
What About Weight-Based Pricing?
With Clutter Cleanout, our 24-hour rental starts at $199 plus $0.09 per pound — so you only pay for the actual weight of your shingles. No pre-set weight caps. No surprise overage fees.
For multi-day roofing jobs, our 1–3 day rentals include weight allowances:
- 15-yard: 4,000 lbs included
- 20-yard: 6,000 lbs included
---
Pro Tips for Roofing Dumpster Placement
1. Position the dumpster directly below the roof edge — saves hours of debris hauling 2. Use plywood under the dumpster on asphalt driveways in summer (we provide free driveway boards) 3. Keep nails contained — magnetic nail sweepers are cheap insurance for your driveway and tires 4. Schedule delivery the day before your tear-off so you start clean
The OSHA roofing safety guidelines also recommend maintaining clear work zones around debris containers — another reason to size up if you're tight on space.
---
Shingle Recycling Note
Ohio supports shingle recycling at select facilities. The Ohio EPA encourages diverting asphalt shingles from landfills, as they can be recycled into road paving material. When we haul your roofing dumpster, recyclable shingles are diverted whenever possible at our transfer facility.
---
Bottom Line: Which Size Should You Pick?
Still not sure? Call (513) 216-1143 — we'll ask a few questions about your roof and tell you exactly what you need. We deliver across Cincinnati, Mason, Florence, Covington, and all 32 cities we serve.
Browse our full roofing dumpster rental page or see all dumpster sizes to compare.